Avedon's 'In the American West' presents us with many issues that documentary practice can often pose. To begin with we must question to what extent the universal objectivity can be practiced? The selection and portrayal of the subjects, especially presenting the topics forced and fashioned will always be based on our individual views, so therefore very often the document can focus on the photographer, rather than the subject that is meant to be documented. Avedon's portraits of the West are detached from the backgrounds, edited in such way that the viewer is to focus purely on the exaggerated features and the characteristics of their occupation. The selection of the subjects is also very questionable leaving us wondering why only manual, dirty workers were chosen to be selected for the project. And this further expands to the bigger issue relevant to the whole world of art, not just photography - the fashioning of public tastes and creation of the art and the position of the artist. A very relevant read here would be Tom Wolfe's 'The Painted Word'. A piece of art can be seen as a promotional material for the artist, the museum and the sponsor. The criticism of the art is often manipulated and can also be very much based on the previous achievements of the artist. The public opinion can be therefore very easily shaped not by the art, but by how the art is perceived by the ruling critics and the press.
Lastly the issue of exploitation must be mentioned here. We must question the extent of the portrayal of the subjects as artist's vision. Diane Arbus was another photographer often accused of extended exploitation. If I was to voice my opinion here, I would have to say that all photography can be exploitative. We, as photographers are meant to be expressing our views and opinions and if we are to be successful they must transpire into our photographs and therefore an element of exploitation is often unavoidable.
Sunday, 5 July 2015
Monday, 29 June 2015
Sunday, 28 June 2015
B&W portraits as a documentary strategy
Zed Nelson's 'Disappearing Britain' B&W project was captured in impromptu studios setup on locations such as mine shaft or the harbour. By removing and separating the subjects from their natural environment we are able to learn a great deal about the individual characters or in this case their classification as a specific worker, but furthermore we are able to find out about working methods or even working conditions. Like Jeff Walls 'Backpack', which was closely based on Manet's 'The Piper', such minimal portraits teach us as much about the individual person as about the ideas of a specific time and era.





Similar qualities can be found in Irving Penn photographs from the project 'Small Trades', again the subject is removed from its surroundings and placed in studio environment in order to supply with a type of classification. Such simplification allows to categorise with ease and with the use of a single photograph.






Similar qualities can be found in Irving Penn photographs from the project 'Small Trades', again the subject is removed from its surroundings and placed in studio environment in order to supply with a type of classification. Such simplification allows to categorise with ease and with the use of a single photograph.

The Father of social classification was August Sander, a
German photographer, who spent most of his life photographing ordinary
individuals with an ambition to create a classification of the 20th
century German society. Despite dedicating to the project over 40 years of his
life, August Sander never completed it.
Sander assigned his photographs into seven categories: ‘The
Farmer’. ‘The Skilled Tradesmen’, ‘The Woman’, ‘Classes and Profession’, ‘The
Artists’, ‘The City’ and ‘The Last People’, which included the elderly and
people with disabilities, birth defects and mental issues. Sander believed in
the hierarchy of occupations and this can be clearly seen in the way the
photographs were captured, i.e. intellectual classes were photographed against
plain backgrounds in studio environment, whilst physical labour in their
natural working surroundings, often with tools of trade included.
August Sander had a very clear vision of the German society of
20th Century. The accuracy of his vision was often questioned back
in his day, with Nazis banning him from working for the lack of glorification
in his photos. Today, we can appreciate the photographs as a comprehensive
collection of social types and classes of Germany, mainly because of their
natural capture and lack of artistry.
I can’t help but to wonder if such classification would work today, i.e. in such vast society as England is? Can we really summarise a modern adult by inserting him or her into a single frame and therefore into a single category? I would hate to think that I am only a PA due to the task of working occupying most of my daily routine. Zed Nelson in his ‘Disappearing Britain’ was successful with his classification, because he concentrated on a niche topic of the disappearing trades and traditions. But without a doubt to create the classification of social types of today would present a great challenge.
Sunday, 14 June 2015
London
London visit yesterday was very amusing. Plenty of entertaining street occurrences, like the Irish dancing church hating Jew and his drunken add on companions (pic below).
On a more serious note, I did manage to finally make my way to The Photographers Gallery in Ramillies Street, where I saw the exhibition of work by a Hungarian born artist Tamas Dezso, who captures post communism era in countries like Hungary and Romania. I clearly remember his work being featured in British Journal of Photography a few months ago, as they stunned me with their clear honesty and an unquestionable beauty. Although the main element of his photographs are poverty and struggle, I can't help but to see them as very poignant and melancholic, almost attempting to seek the beauty amongst the constantly deteriorating landscape and its inhabitants. Examples of his work below.
Monday, 25 May 2015
May and more delays
It is now the end of May and I'm still unpacking in my new place. Brighton is fantastic, but somehow my camera has not ventured outside yet. Is she perhaps too provincial to match the sophistication of the big city? Does she need a little more time to deal with her shyness? In all honesty, it has been too manic to even consider documenting the experience of the last few months with the camera. I never claimed to be one of the passionate individuals, who reach for their capturing companion in all situations. I prefer to snap when things are calmer.
Anyway, the move has been a bit of a nightmare. It has taken us an extra month to find somewhere to live in Brighton, during which I had to contain my life into a tiny flat in Alderney. We are now here and have been working hard over the last few weeks to establish a comfortable base for the future months. In between Birthdays, Guests and trips in and out of the Channel Islands, today is the first morning that I managed to sit myself in front of the blogger and consider writing an update. I am finally starting to see some clear space, which I can hopefully fill with my creative interests.
Some photos summarising the last few months, I have not been completely useless photographically.
Anyway, the move has been a bit of a nightmare. It has taken us an extra month to find somewhere to live in Brighton, during which I had to contain my life into a tiny flat in Alderney. We are now here and have been working hard over the last few weeks to establish a comfortable base for the future months. In between Birthdays, Guests and trips in and out of the Channel Islands, today is the first morning that I managed to sit myself in front of the blogger and consider writing an update. I am finally starting to see some clear space, which I can hopefully fill with my creative interests.
Some photos summarising the last few months, I have not been completely useless photographically.
Thursday, 18 December 2014
The big move
It's official, we have sold the house and are finally moving to the Mainland UK. I will be taking a few month off OCA study in order to move the house and study towards the Life in UK test to get my British citizenship. I shall be back at the end of April!
Thursday, 11 December 2014
Research point - Semiotics
Semiotics is the study of signs and symbols, in photography it involves the reading of a picture and its meaning. It is the interpretation of the photograph rather than its translation.
As photographers and/or viewers of photography we must consider the representation and therefore what a photographer attempts to represent with the photograph. Ferdinand de Saussure, the Swiss inventor of the theory of semiotics argued that a written and visual language is based on a system of signs composed of 'a signifier' (the form which the sign takes) and 'the signified' (the concept it represents). An American philosopher Charles Sanders Peirce, who also developed a theory on semiotics used a three part model based around 'the representamen' (the form that the sign takes; not necessarily material), 'an interpretant' (the sense made of the sign) and 'an object' (to which the sign refers).
There are a few significant points in the understanding of semiotics, i.e the signifier does not resemble the signified in relation to a symbol, the relationship between the two is based on our knowledge and therefore it must be learnt. Here perhaps it is worth mentioning such questions as subjectivity and cultural differences, the elements crucial for decoding a photograph, questions raised by Roland Barthes, the French literary theorist, philosopher and semiotician in his book 'Camera Lucida'. Icons on the other hand are a little different, as the signifier resembles or imitates the signified. Further to this we must also remember about indexicality, in which case a signifier is physically connected to the signified, i.e. smoke indicates fire or heat, tears sadness, etc.
As photographers and/or viewers of photography we must consider the representation and therefore what a photographer attempts to represent with the photograph. Ferdinand de Saussure, the Swiss inventor of the theory of semiotics argued that a written and visual language is based on a system of signs composed of 'a signifier' (the form which the sign takes) and 'the signified' (the concept it represents). An American philosopher Charles Sanders Peirce, who also developed a theory on semiotics used a three part model based around 'the representamen' (the form that the sign takes; not necessarily material), 'an interpretant' (the sense made of the sign) and 'an object' (to which the sign refers).
There are a few significant points in the understanding of semiotics, i.e the signifier does not resemble the signified in relation to a symbol, the relationship between the two is based on our knowledge and therefore it must be learnt. Here perhaps it is worth mentioning such questions as subjectivity and cultural differences, the elements crucial for decoding a photograph, questions raised by Roland Barthes, the French literary theorist, philosopher and semiotician in his book 'Camera Lucida'. Icons on the other hand are a little different, as the signifier resembles or imitates the signified. Further to this we must also remember about indexicality, in which case a signifier is physically connected to the signified, i.e. smoke indicates fire or heat, tears sadness, etc.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
































